Thursday, November 13, 2014

Tobacco Picking Near Motueka. Comments

Rating: 0.0

It was my first experience of hard labour,
working in the green fields under the sun,
on a long working holiday near Motueka.
...
Read full text

Michael Walker
COMMENTS
Bri Edwards 08 November 2020

So tobacco is 'evil'? I was never a 'smoker' but worked around enough at times, enough meaning at least one. But i feel smokers derive benefits from smoking (sometimes at least) , a calming effect perhaps, which may make up for some of the negatives, like burning in a house fire, or getting cancer or emphysema! A person in a formerly 'big tobacco-growing state' in the U.S. told me, or i read it, that before pesticides etc., tobacco 'never caused cancer'. to MyPoemList bri :)

0 0 Reply
Michael Walker 05 July 2020

I cannot see your 5 poems posted as yet. M.Walker.

0 0 Reply
Cowboy Ron Williams 01 July 2020

Hmmm.... never done a villanelle before. You did a good job with this one. I would invite you to read my poems (I have five of them) but my account is new and Poem Hunter has not activated them yet. I don't understand this. I thought people would be able to read them at once when they were posted!

0 0 Reply
Glen Kappy 21 August 2019

You made the villanelle form work (no pun intended) in this poem, Michael—the repetitions flow naturally. -Glen

0 0 Reply
Jane Campion 07 July 2019

I loved the feeling and images in your poem. It tells an important early story. It has the flavor of the South Island. I have been there.

0 0 Reply
Michael Walker 08 July 2019

Thanks for such an encouraging comment, especially that it has 'the flavor of the South Island'. As a North Islander, that's what I was hoping to achieve.

0 0
Terry Craddock 09 January 2017

'I picked the larger green leaves at ground level first, moving along the rows and up the plants to smaller ones' history past, the government outlawed the crop, a have a friend who lives next to be empty former tobacco drying sheds, empty of everything except air

1 0 Reply
Michael Walker 08 July 2019

Your comment updates nicely what has happened to tobacco growing since I was there 50 years ago. Thanks.

0 0
Michael Walker 08 July 2019

Thanks for your quote of two lines and updating comment too.

0 0
Maria Gonzalez 26 October 2015

A well crafted narrative Michael. I enjoyed it. Thank you.

1 0 Reply
Michael Walker 05 May 2018

Thanks for calling in to this poem and analyzing it so well. That work experience happened 50-plus years ago.

0 0
Douglas Scotney 15 June 2015

I had a similar baptism cutting duboisia leaves in 1974 for medicinal drugs near Kingaroy. A longer-standing employee went a bit crazy and I decided to quit before I did too. Written in a matter-of-fact style that's quite intriguing. You've moved on.

1 0 Reply
Michael Walker 05 May 2018

I don't blame you for quitting early: not worth the risk of being attacked. I had to earn money in many different ways as a student, still good days to look back on.

0 0
Eugene Levich 23 February 2015

A nice evocation of a memorable experience and an effective, poetic, slice of life. Bien fait!

1 0 Reply
Michael Walker 05 May 2018

Thanks Eugene. It all happened more than 50 years ago now. I gave up smoking when I was 30, thank goodness.

0 0
Lyn Paul 13 November 2014

All those years ago no one thought. Interesting write

1 0 Reply
Michael Walker 08 July 2019

Thanks for noticing one of my earliest poems. One of the most popular, I think.

0 0
Kumarmani Mahakul 13 November 2014

Picking tobacco for long time at last you realized the negatives of its is really amazing poem of awareness. Nicely penned.

1 0 Reply
Michael Walker 05 May 2018

Yes, I realize the negatives of smoking now-having stopped when I was 30- but I used to smoke for quite a few years until I saw the light. Thanks for your analysis.

0 0
Michael Walker

Michael Walker

cv48488
Close
Error Success