Friday, January 3, 2003

The Red Wheelbarrow Comments

Rating: 3.7

so much depends
upon

a red wheel
...
Read full text

William Carlos Williams
red
COMMENTS
Varsha M 04 February 2021

WCW can create meaning out of everything. Red wheel barrow might have no space in common life but to lay foundation it plays integral role.

2 0 Reply
Rose Marie Juan-austin 03 February 2021

Succinct yet full of images.

1 0 Reply
Sylvia Frances Chan 03 February 2021

A simple poem, but very thought-provoking. Congratulations on being chosen by Poem Hunter as The Classic Poem Of The Day!

2 0 Reply
Mahtab Bangalee 18 February 2020

a red wheel barrow glazed with rain water ///////// SIMPLY GREAT POEM PENNED

2 0 Reply
Hugh David Morgan. 26 January 2020

The poem simply stresses the total dependence of all poetry on images.

1 0 Reply
Wolf queen 23 October 2018

The whit chickens representing the white man crakes the wip all day as if there is nothing to do

1 3 Reply
harvey 22 August 2019

and the rain represents the of god on your head

0 0
Wolf queen 23 October 2018

The red wheelbarrow represents the blood of black pepole glistening after the rain as

2 5 Reply
Danny A. Leiva 24 September 2018

is this poem about beer?

2 4 Reply
Bewildered reader 08 May 2018

How is this a famous poem I don’t understand why is it so revered I don’t get it at all

7 7 Reply
Juanita Rosenberg 13 March 2018

I agree about the reader, replace the video.

5 4 Reply
Tom Gerber 02 August 2017

The person reading this poem is an absolutely abysmal reader. Wm. Carlos Williams would spin in his grave if he heard her read. Terrible... Get The Hook.

4 6 Reply
Fabrizio Frosini 28 January 2016

IN ITALIAN: ‘La carriola rossa’ Così tanto dipende dalla ruota rossa d’una carriola lucida d’acqua piovana accanto ai polli bianchi. (William Carlos Williams,1923)

14 5 Reply
Frank Avon 17 September 2014

Williams would probably be amazed if he knew that his reputation as a poet is so dependent upon two of his imagistic poems, this on and This Is Just To Say. For me, they are both truly great poems, among the best by US poets. Once I was dictating this poem from memory to a class. Except that I quoted the last two lines as beside the five white / chickens. When a student pointed out my mistake, I realized the picture in my mind was so vivid that I could not forget that, in my imagination, there were five white chickens. (Well, there's also the assonance with beside and white.) I'm not sure whether I should attribute this to the vividness of the poem or the strength of my imagination. Even today, many years later, I cannot recite the poem without seeing in my mind five white chickens picking and pecking on the ground beside the red wheelbarrow. Would that I could just once write eight such memorable lines.

27 7 Reply
Greg Bell 31 May 2020

Frank, I think your anecdote gives testimony of the imagistic power of the poem ('no ideas but in things'...) gb

0 0
Greg Bell 31 May 2020

Frank, your anecdote is testimony, innit, to the imagistic power of the poem ('no ideas but in things...) evoking memory & imagination. gb

0 0
Vincent Trinidad 24 June 2014

this poem is terrible

34 60 Reply
* Sunprincess * 18 June 2014

............oh this piece is so imaginative....a red wheelbarrow definitely means someone is going to do some work.....

18 7 Reply

Very good imigery... almost haiku like..I studied this poem in college many years ago and its image has always stayed with me...it's true it gives many meanings to the readers but the poet could have had many ideas, too...many of these poems have a secret meaning..does only the poet know the truth? That's the beauty of writing abstract poetry...the space between the words...and the solid picture defines..we see what we want to see and feel as we want...

18 8 Reply
Alyssa Newton 27 February 2014

We had an assignment just recently in my english class for this poem. We had to take the image painted by Williams and create a story around it. It was purely inventive, and despite the consistent image, no two stories were alike. I think that's the real point of this poem, and imagist poetry in general. Even all writing in general, come to think of it. Sure, it may be about something specific, or it may mean something particular to the writer. That will always be a thing. But what is important is that it means something to the reader, and moreso that it means something different to every reader. So I think the utter abstractness of this poem is because we are supposed to give it our own meaning. We are supposed to make it our own.

25 5 Reply
D Sterling 16 February 2014

lol lol lol lol lol lol lol lol

24 18 Reply
Myles Sweeney 07 January 2014

Possible, Billy. However, W.C Williams had a child who was ill. As he sat in the child's room, he could look out the window and see a red wheelbarrow in the yard. As the child's condition worsened, he convinced himself that if the child could only get well enough to walk from his bed to the wheelbarrow without help, he would be okay... The child eventually died, so I think the poem is about how we attach such importance to such arbitrary things in our lives to mask what really matters. We try to fool everyone, and in the end we only fool ourselves.

33 11 Reply
Myles Sweeney 07 January 2014

Possible, Billy. However, W.C Williams had a child who was ill. As he sat in the child's room, he could look out the window and see a red wheelbarrow in the yard. As the child's condition worsened, he convinced himself that if the child could only get well enough to walk from his bed to the wheelbarrow without help, he would be okay... The child eventually died, so I think the poem is about how we attach such importance to such arbitrary things in our lives to mask what really matters. We try to fool everyone, and in the end we only fool ourselves.

13 11 Reply
Greg Bell 31 May 2020

Myles, is that a known biographical fact? Makes a lot of sense for the urgency of the 1st line. Of course, the charm of the poem is that the images offer up themselves for any interpretation, depending on the reader and his/her personal experience & imagination. I'd be interested to know, though, if it's autobiographically documented. Thx gb

0 0
Close
Error Success