Friday, January 3, 2003

The Nightingale's Nest Comments

Rating: 2.8

Up this green woodland-ride let’s softly rove,
And list the nightingale - she dwells just here.
Hush ! let the wood-gate softly clap, for fear
The noise might drive her from her home of love ;
...
Read full text

John Clare
COMMENTS
John Johnson 17 August 2020

Why do I get this feeling that he focused on leaving the nest and surrounds as they are, and listening to the song from afar as it ought to be, because of his own personal experiences? I don't think he merely records nature at all, it's highly selective, he comments and instructs gracefully, makes us focus imaginatively without drifting into fanciful personifications. Could it be that this narrator has the attitude he wished his readers could have had?

1 0 Reply
Steve 29 April 2020

Seems to me this is about nature and the excitement of engaging with it. Keats poem is, itseems to me, about the human condition, but this has nature as the fabric of the nest, the poem and of our excitement at finding and seeing the nest.

1 0 Reply
Leon Dupasind 25 July 2018

It is the male nightingale that sings. Not the female.

2 2 Reply
Jim Nairn 04 September 2018

While that's worth pointing out, I don't feel it detracts from the poem. Writers often assumed it was the female who sang & it interesting to think why (and the connotation that had etc.) . Clare certainly knew the natural world, and as Tim Dee points out in his poetry anthology, he wrote about 150 species of British birds without any technical kit

1 0
Carol Schultz 21 June 2016

Clare keeps his poems focused on the subject matter not turning to his feelings about it. Dr. Tom Dillingham, our teacher.

1 2 Reply
Carol Schultz 21 June 2016

A class with Osher Lifelong Learning Institute at Mizzou brought me here. Very beautiful.

0 0 Reply
Susan Williams 30 December 2015

It's a little old-fashioned but beauty abounds in its every verse.

23 3 Reply
david bailie 25 December 2017

Old Fashioned.... I don't think so... David Attenborough whose programmes are full of such descriptions would give his right arm, I suspect, to have half the ability to use such majestic phrasing of our language.. Aside from thatClassics are classics for one of the facts that they are ageless and readable a million times!

1 0
David Stewart 10 July 2012

So many words and poems out there... The nightingale's nest by John Clair, 'I was unaware... Thanks to George-George Monbiot, with out his direction Clairs poems would be to me lost not sought... Beautiful poem!

8 1 Reply
Steve Tucker 15 February 2012

Gosh, this poem is so beautiful!

10 3 Reply
Imogen c 11 October 2007

it is a great pitty if i am the only one who has visted this page

9 3 Reply
John Clare

John Clare

Northamptonshire / England
Close
Error Success