Wednesday, May 16, 2001

Sailing To Byzantium Comments

Rating: 3.7

That is no country for old men. The young
In one another's arms, birds in the trees
---Those dying generations---at their song,
The salmon-falls, the mackerel-crowded seas,
...
Read full text

William Butler Yeats
COMMENTS
Terence Craddock 20 May 2023

A really beautiful contrast to this poem by Yeats is 'I Am Listening to Istanbul', by the famous Turkish poet Orhan Veli Kanik. An exquisite poem.

0 0 Reply
Terence Craddock 20 May 2023

I like aspects of 'Sailing to Byzantium' by Yeats, but it is obvious Yeats had not been there, the light, the colour, the smells are all missing.

0 0 Reply
Ramesh T A 20 May 2023

Yeats simply says through this poem that the animate nature is devoid of spirit and temporary only but the inanimate art, poetry created by him is full of spirit and is immortal and permanent.

0 0 Reply
David W Choate 27 July 2020

In My Top five Poems. Swapping places at times with William Blake's Tyger Tyger for the number one spot. Ever since I figured out how to read Blake's Rhyming. I have yet to hear any Poetry Reader rhyme " What immortal hand or eye" correctly to " frame thy fearful symmetry" Eye and 'try' in symmetry gots to rhyme yo.

0 1 Reply
David Choate 27 June 2020

You Have to Hear Terence McKenna Read It.

1 2 Reply
Michael Walker 05 December 2019

Another poem by Yeats which I studied at university, and have never forgotten. 'This is no country for old men.' Like my country in a way. 'all neglect/ Monuments of unaging intellect'. The young have different tastes than the old, for sure.

2 1 Reply
Francie Lynch 20 February 2015

I like The Fiddler of Dooley as much.

4 1 Reply
you 07 August 2022

you

0 0
* Sunprincess * 09 June 2014

..........a marvelous masterpiece......I too, would love to be a crown fashioned purely from Byzantium gold... and set with diamonds....

10 2 Reply
Donal Byrne 21 January 2013

This is poem about the brevity of youth and beauty It is written with such insight and majesty that i am overwhelmed. We all have lived or are living or soon will this glorious brief spell Remember and revel in it to the depths of your soul then Let go Donal

18 12 Reply
William F Dougherty 25 April 2012

One of the signal poems of the Twentieth Century, included in every anthology of English poetry.

24 9 Reply
Peter Stavropoulos 24 October 2009

A joy to read and to listen to. Hearing Yeats read it on YouTube is a treat.

18 11 Reply
Michael Harmon 10 August 2009

I believe (correctly, I hope) it was Henry Ford, the creator of the production line for auto manufacturing, who, when asked about the color for his automobiles, famously said: 'You can have any color you like, as long as it's black.' I believe you can rate this poem any way you like, as long as it's 10. :)

17 13 Reply
Raj Nandy 20 April 2009

THIS HAS BECOME A TIMELESS CLASSICAL PIECE OF POETRY & IS ALSO INCLUDED IN THE CURRICULUM OF ENGLISH LITERATURE OF MANY UNIVERSITIES! PEOPLE DARING TO RATE SUCH A MASTERPIECE DO NO DISCRETID TO YEATS - BUT ONLY TO THEMSELVES! ! ! ! ! -RAJ NANDY

11 18 Reply
ari anna arena 02 February 2007

This could possibly be almost the perfect poem! Certainly one of the most beautiful with nearly every poetic nuance and technique represented. What a guy, that Yeats. Love him. Love this.

12 12 Reply
Mesho Saleh 05 December 2006

this poem is so great, it compains myth with reality.

11 11 Reply
Ann Goodchild 15 June 2005

Probably one of the most beautiful and under-rated poems ever

12 11 Reply
William Butler Yeats

William Butler Yeats

County Dublin / Ireland
Close
Error Success