Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Quiet Eyes Comments

Rating: 3.3

The boys come home, come home from war,
With quiet eyes for quiet things --
A child, a lamb, a flower, a star,
A bird that softly sings.
...
Read full text

Katharine Tynan
COMMENTS
Susan Williams 10 August 2018

I'm glad this was selected POTD again- -I think she is a clever intelligent poet and I shall read more by her this time around.

0 0 Reply
Kumarmani Mahakul 10 August 2018

This is my second visit to this poem that is selected as POD. for second time just after one year. Congratulations.

0 0 Reply
Glen Kappy 10 August 2018

The last two lines of this poem being contrary to my understanding of what taking life does to a soul, I wonder if Tynan was being ironic, stating the opposite of what was true. Are not the nightmares and physical signs she notes evidence of what has happened to soldiers’ souls? -GK

1 0 Reply
Susan Williams 10 August 2018

That's what I was thinking too, Glen. She sounds too intelligent about the boys' homecoming to believe their soul untouched

0 0
Anil Kumar Panda 10 August 2018

A very sad poem indeed about kids returning from wars and their scars in heart and mind. Excellent.

0 0 Reply
Adrian Flett 10 August 2018

'The soul looks from its hidden place' The sad ravages of war.

0 0 Reply
Dr Antony Theodore 10 August 2018

The worldling's eyes are dusty dim, The eyes of sin are weary and cold, a very good poem indeed. tony

0 0 Reply
Lungelo S Mbuyazi 10 August 2018

A deeply sad write about the human struggle to do what thought is right for human race

0 0 Reply
Paul Brookes 10 August 2018

The sadness and leaving and losing part of yourself War may not kill the participants but it surly scars them Great piece of writing.

1 0 Reply
Ruta Mohapatra 10 August 2018

'The soul looks from its hidden place Unharmed, unflawed, unhurt'.........So the soul remains untouched by worldly events! Vedic philosophy!

1 0 Reply
Fredrick Nemes 10 August 2018

let us hear them war stories, for the boys are now men, They are home from war, With stories to share though with tears and blood.

1 0 Reply
Mahtab Bangalee 10 August 2018

Excellent Writing- As nightmare dreams that pass with sleep, The horror and grief intolerable. The unremembering young eyes keep Their innocence. All is well! ..... All is well! All is well! All is well!

1 0 Reply
Bernard F. Asuncion 10 August 2017

Nice and touching poem....

1 0 Reply
Susan Williams 10 August 2017

Extraordinary piece of writing. Recognizing PTSD so many years ago. I thought we'd only recently recognized this.

3 0 Reply
Rajesh Thankappan 10 August 2017

The soldiers who return back alive from war carry with them their nightmarish past and if their eyes have some unsullied eyes of past, it should be because of man's yearning for peace and harmony.

1 0 Reply
Kumarmani Mahakul 10 August 2017

Insightful poem. The war has furrowed the young face. Oh, there's no all-heal, no wound-wort! The soul looks from its hidden place Unharmed, unflawed, unhurt. Congratulation to his / her soul.

0 0 Reply
Seamus O Brian 10 August 2017

Powerful writing. I have thought previously that no one ever comes home from war. Those who return are never the same people as those who ventured out. But this piece argues for a part of the soul that remains unharmed by the horror of war. Something to contemplate, but exquisitely wrought nonetheless...

1 0 Reply
Edward Kofi Louis 10 August 2017

The eye of sin are weary and cold! ! Thanks for sharing this poem with us.

1 0 Reply
Anil Kumar Panda 10 August 2017

Parents are the most happiest people when they see their sons return from war unharmed. Though bruised and looking tired as oldmen for them they are their little boys. Very nice. Congrats. The war has furrowed the young face. Oh, there's no all-heal, no wound-wort! The soul looks from its hidden place Unharmed, unflawed, unhurt. ......is a very nice stanza.

1 0 Reply
Jayatissa K. Liyanage 10 August 2017

In whatever form boys come home from war front, so long as they are amongst living, parents will be the happiest to receive them. However much they are changed over time, still, they are their boys. Very thoughtful and sensational indeed. Thanks for sharing. Congrats for the positioning.

1 0 Reply
Kayode Are 10 August 2017

Boys always come home from war as men. Still the adoration of assumed innocence resonate in the lines.

1 0 Reply
Katharine Tynan

Katharine Tynan

23 January 1861 – 2 April 1931
Close
Error Success