Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Questions Of You. Comments

Rating: 4.9

What are you trying to sell
But then just give away?
What is it your dreaming of
As the night fades to day?
...
Read full text

J.A McManus
COMMENTS
Charlotte Riley 21 December 2009

I havent read many poems who speak directly to the audience I like it, it's a very clever poem. What does this line mean? ? 'What kind of truth do you seek In my old house of lies? '

0 0 Reply
Sayz LFlynn 01 December 2009

Always questions, never answers, wounderful poem, keep writing: D

0 0 Reply
Terence Nabbs 30 November 2009

hi john Ive wrestled with these two imotions most of my life but i plumped for love. good poem. terence

0 0 Reply
Shamik Kumar Bose 27 November 2009

I amnot sure if it is addressed to your kids, John. The flow of the poems is superb, with meanings simple and profound.

0 0 Reply
Sandra Martyres 27 November 2009

I agree with all who have commented on this well crafted poem....the essence of which is reflected in the last stanza....it is we and we alone who can choose whether to love or hate and how to do either....10+++

0 0 Reply
Fay Slimm 27 November 2009

The final two questions are to me the maxim of the verse - 'do you love with tenderness - or do you hate with rage' - -we can choose to live with either emotion uppermost in our life - - but the vital answers to those questions will determine how we appear to ourselves and to the world.... a well thought out verse Jon.... keep writing do....10/10 from Fay.

0 0 Reply
Susan Jarvis 27 November 2009

Full of mystery and intrigue - a compelling read! S :)

0 0 Reply
Clara Odelia Ciutara 27 November 2009

THis is a wonderful poem, John. You wrote in an easy way to understand, and I love each part of this poem. They are good.

0 0 Reply

I really admire the way John Knight has commented on this poem and has taken it as being for him in the critique. I love the rhythm and rhyme and it has much depth. Questions, if they are pertinent, involve the reader as yours do so well. As I got down to the end I realized, and this is what I believe, we all create our own reality almost completely, and we can choose to love or hate. 10 Karin (although the votes don't seem to be working) .

0 0 Reply

i afree with Jon, good structure, rhythm etc. with time better thing. the facets made it reflective of deep thought. good!

0 0 Reply

i afree with Jon, good structure, rhythm etc. with time better thing. the facets made it reflective of deep thought. good!

0 0 Reply
bye bye... bye bye 26 November 2009

Do you love with tenderness Or do you hate with rage? Clever and interesting questions. I like the little word 'or'. We have a choice.

0 0 Reply
John Knight 26 November 2009

Hi John - Good structure - rythm and rhyme also content - well worthy of a MAX. Poems which ask questions are always interesting especially if the adressee is anonymous. Because of the last verse (in particular) I will analyse it as if it was addressed to me. V 1 Selling - giving away - dreaming in the twilight of life. Personally I deal in TRUTH I dream of (possessing) WISDOM. V 2 Primarily I seek for SPIRITUAL TRUTH - The Nature of God - The Meaning of Life. We all wear masks to enable us to communicate in the real World, especially if we are communicating TRUTH. I wear a smile! V 3 I look for KNOWLEDGE & TRUTH & UNDERSTANDING to enable me to become WISE. FAITH is a Belief System - there are many and each individual must choose. The White Angel is a Universal Symbol of Peace - Her I embrace. The Cold Fingered Wraith is an agent of Satan - I abhor the Wraith - but (because I am a Christian) I do not fear Him. V 4 As I grow older 'Though the Outer Man perishes the Inner Man is renewed day-by day. Love is the answer to all the needs of the World and its six billion inhabitants - Love without Tenderness is an oxymoron as is Hate without Rage - I choose TLC Tender Loving Care. Yours in Poetry - JOHN

0 0 Reply
Joseph Poewhit 26 November 2009

Part of the game - WHO ARE THE PIECES AND PLAYERS? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?

0 0 Reply
Alf Hutchison 26 November 2009

Hello John...at last someone with rhythm and rhyme... either we are 'outdated' or it is the most difficult poetry to write... non-the-less excellent penning my young friend...have a look at my 'poet or author'...regards Alf

0 0 Reply
Luwi Habte 26 November 2009

wonderful, that is all i can say love the poem luwi

0 0 Reply
Emilie DeVere 25 November 2009

Very good, simple poem. You're not using flowery vocabulary and fancy words, and that's what I like about this. It's simple, true and it flows together. Great job!

0 0 Reply
Patti Masterman 18 November 2009

Some intriguing questions in this one. Like the mask of disguise. (smile)

0 0 Reply
J.A McManus

J.A McManus

Carlisle, Cumbria
Close
Error Success