Monday, July 24, 2006

'Proportionality'. A Disgusted Rant. Comments

Rating: 2.3

We here in Britain have a traditional
belief in fair play.
Like, if we lose an away match,
we trash their town centre,
...
Read full text

Michael Shepherd
COMMENTS
Declan McHenry 24 July 2006

Michael, I had to laugh at this fiirst as I spent the afternoon explaining the reasons for disproportionality in anti-terrorism stop and search statistics today! You've pulled together a grand argument that you drive through the poem. I like works like that which take the reader along with them and then suddenly open their eyes. Enlightening write Michael. Cheers.

0 0 Reply
Esther Leclerc 24 July 2006

Excellent comparison of 'proportionality' in different settings, an altogether apt and worthy rant, if ever I read one. And too, well, I had to laugh at the Waterloo bit, having experienced the latter first hand and fascinated by the former. Proportionality... fair play... sportsmanship... war as sport with an absence of anything resembling humanity (even for the dead) ... You've said a mouthful, Michael.

0 0 Reply

As a rant, I absolutely agree, goes without saying. I think the structure works, too - told as if an ironic depiction of a schoolmaster (heh heh) explaining what this British 'tradition' (my arse) means. Good continued match analogy, too. 'Would anyone notice'... perhaps the most troubling question. In short: well said. t x

0 0 Reply
Gina Onyemaechi 24 July 2006

As to the message, hear hear! ! As to the form....

0 0 Reply
Michael Shepherd

Michael Shepherd

Marton, Lancashire
Close
Error Success