Thursday, April 15, 2010

On The Aphorism Comments

Rating: 2.8

'L'Amitié est l'Amour sans ailes.'
FRIENDSHIP, as some sage poet sings,
Is chasten'd Love, depriv'd of wings,
...
Read full text

Charlotte Smith
COMMENTS
Subhas Chandra Chakra 29 April 2018

I loved this stanza so much..To quote And she, who years beyond fifteen, Has counted twenty, may have seen How rarely unplum'd Love will stay; He flies not­but he coolly walks away. Thanks for the sharing.

0 0 Reply
Rks Yadav 29 April 2018

beautifully felt and penned

0 0 Reply
Henry Tong 29 April 2018

However, the genius of this poem lies on the second stanza, as the interaction between He and She becomes unclear and intertwined- the poet doesn't give a clear hint of how rarely unplumed love will stay, but instead suggests many alternatives leaving the audience an open end of story.

1 0 Reply
Henry Tong 29 April 2018

Intimacy, Passion and Commitment are three quintessential factors of Loving. Here, the poet differentiates liking and loving in that liking is constituted of intimacy only, but loving needs to be satisfied all of three.

1 0 Reply
Marieta Maglas 29 April 2018

In this poem as in many others, the aphorisms are didactic and instructive. Like Anne Carson, Suzanne Buffam, Chelsey Minnis, or Elizabeth Willis, Charlotte Smith uses the lyric aphorism to explain a model of logic, an accumulative one. beautiful poem. Voted 10.

0 0 Reply
Bernard F. Asuncion 29 April 2018

Such a great write by Charlotte Smith👍👍👍

2 0 Reply
Edward Kofi Louis 29 April 2018

'Love creeps, even where he cannot go'! Thanks for sharing.

2 0 Reply
Close
Error Success