Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Like Sentries (Plus Tanka Version Dedicated To Nora Olmedo) Comments

Rating: 4.6

There they were

Up there!

East West North South
...
Read full text

Sonya Florentino
COMMENTS
Lillian Thomas 29 September 2009

Both are very well-crafted, beautiful images. I guess I prefer the tanka by a little, because it gives it more context, it sets up a certain expectation that it certainly delivers. Now I'm going to have to get acquainted with Nora Olmeda's work.

0 0 Reply
Yelena M. 05 September 2009

Sonya, I love both versions of your delicate write. I agree with Sandra, the original one takes me a bit 'higher' in its expression. A beautiful birdy poem, thanks for sharing :) Yelena M.

0 0 Reply
Sandra Martyres 04 September 2009

Both versions are nice Sonya, but I prefer the Tanka one....perhaps because I like the discipline of the syllable count and besides as Karin says it helps add to the meaning of the piece.....Nice tribute to Nora's poetic prowess...10+

0 0 Reply

Lovely to see your dedication to a fine poet Nora Olmedo. I prefer the Tanka Version as I feel the syllable count of Tanka gives the poem more substance and credence. However, if they were mine, I would be proud of them both Sonya. 10 love Karin

0 0 Reply
nomad omnia 31 August 2009

Hmmm, I like the spontanaeity of the first version, as if written in the moment. The second version feels more reflective. Again, great to see the same subject presented in different way - thanks Sonya.

0 0 Reply
Sandra Fowler 30 August 2009

I prefer the spare, elegant imagery of the original version. 'frayed afternoon' is especially compelling. As always, Sandra

0 0 Reply
Naseer Ahmed Nasir 30 August 2009

A mundane observation turned wonderfully into multidimensional poetry and then dedicated to a respected and humble poetess, well done Sonya! Love and Regards, Naseer

0 0 Reply
Ruth Walters 30 August 2009

I like the Tanka version better than the original! Ruthy: -)

0 0 Reply
Laurie Hill 29 August 2009

Winged sentinels? ................

0 0 Reply
Susan Jarvis 29 August 2009

A superb and strangely reassuring image. I adore the 'frayed afternoon' of the final line - I've had a few of those! S ;)

0 0 Reply
Sonya Florentino 27 August 2009

Obinna, they were actually pigeons, just ordinary pigeons.. but they could as well have been angels (wearing dark sentry uniforms...?)

0 0 Reply
Obinna Eruchie 27 August 2009

I would rather say that the birds are doves, after all they represent peace and the Holy Spirit. More like peace in your life is secured by God's angels. Beautiful!

0 0 Reply
Kesav Easwaran 26 August 2009

nice observation...nice words...nicer presentation...thanks Sonya...10

0 0 Reply
Rakesh Bedi 25 August 2009

Holding your word in all the four directions; like God send Angels, a very nice poem with a metaphysical vision between the lines!

0 0 Reply
Patti Masterman 25 August 2009

I know this feeling well. Just glad the birds were on guard duty. Pigeons, maybe? (smile) On Sundays, I like to say that the pigeons are in church (up on top all the roofs) .

0 0 Reply
Sonya Florentino

Sonya Florentino

Manila, Philippines (residing NYC)
Close
Error Success