Friday, January 3, 2003

In A Minor Key Comments

Rating: 2.8

(AN ECHO FROM A LARGER LYRE.)


That was love that I had before
...
Read full text

Amy Levy
COMMENTS
Sylvia Frances Chan 19 September 2019

I cite here one more stanza, the final, I regard all are most beautifully thought and worded: But, ere I could reach you where you lay, Must strength and substance and honour spend; Journey long journeys by night and day- Somehow, I think I should come, my friend! True mesmerizing and she captured all loveliest. A most deserving CLASSIC Poem Of The Day, Hurray! Once again my CONGRATULATIONS for her family. God´s Blessings!

0 0 Reply
Sylvia Frances Chan 19 September 2019

Fourteen stanzas long, all stanzas of the same beauty and best end rhymes, this lady shows much talent and much attention for the written word, enjoyed all stanzas and I have chosen one to cite here: And yet- and yet- I scarce can tell why (As I said, we are riddles and hard to read) , If the world went ill with you, and I Could help with a hidden hand your need; Truly enjoyed such talented gift of Amy Levy. CONGRATULATIONS for the family.

0 0 Reply
Benjamin Uy 19 September 2019

Love is the deepest emotion well in our life, The greatest contrasts between major and minor keys, Love beyond splendor and squalor, The grand orchestra we are attending, Great poem from the poet

0 0 Reply
Practicing Poetess 19 September 2019

'Soul has its tones and its semitones, Mind has its major and minor keys.' Classic poetry. A fitting choice for Poem of the Day! A fitting choice for Poem of the Day

3 0 Reply
Dr Antony Theodore 19 September 2019

hat was love that I had before Years ago, when my heart was young; Ev'ry smile was a gem you wore; Ev'ry word was a sweet song sung.... doomed to part. pain suffering separation. very fine poem.

1 0 Reply
Kumarmani Mahakul 19 September 2019

Ev'ry smile was a gem you wore; Ev'ry word was a sweet song sung.......much impressive with lofty theme, It is glad that this poem has been selected as the poem of the day for second time.

0 0 Reply
Tamara Beryl Latham 19 September 2019

Beautiful rhyming poem, Amy. Bravo!

0 0 Reply
Ratnakar Mandlik 19 September 2019

Love in young age and when the person is old and matured depicted with it's intensity and colorful facets. A brilliant classic deserving classic of the day.

1 0 Reply
Kingsley Egbukole 19 September 2019

A beautiful love poem. Kingsley Egbukole

1 0 Reply
Paul Brookes 19 September 2019

There is a feeling of a 'Love that dare not speak its name.' and one wonders if there is a strain of surpressed homosexuality in the poem. Having said that it is such beautiful and heart rending piece that can be read on many levels with much hidden meaning.

2 0 Reply
Jim Hogg 19 September 2019

I'd go further, Paul. It's bravely exposed imv. There would have been little doubt about what she was revealing in the circles she moved in, in those very constrained times.

0 0
Edward Kofi Louis 19 September 2018

Years ago! ! Thanks for sharing this poem with us.

1 0 Reply
Glen Kappy 19 September 2018

Intended as such or not, this is a meditation on how romantic feelings change over time—and a finely written one. For myself, I haven’t experienced the excruciating desire of adolescence since then and have no desire to revisit it. But this poem causes us to ask what love is. And what is it within marriage, for example, when over more than four decades, in my case, we go through all the changes that are part of aging. A feeling? A commitment? -GK

1 1 Reply
Sylvia Frances Chan 19 September 2018

TWO: Despite her very busy activities and though she was well educated in literature, Amy Levy suffered from a diagnose of major depression since her early years. Must be noted that she committed suicide at the age of 27. Her era was the Victorian period, remarkable 14 stanzas long to decide whether to go or not, visiting her sick old friend. Oscar Wilde wrote an obituary for her in Women's World in which he praised her gifts. May she R.I.P.

1 0 Reply
Sylvia Frances Chan 19 September 2018

ONE: Congratulations being chosen as the Classic Poem Of The Day. The poetess had love when her heart was young, all was full of passion, but finally when she had to go to visit the sick old friend, that was hard to do, e.g. long journeys by night and day to spend, and the strength, substance and honor, but at last she decided to come.

1 0 Reply
Kumarmani Mahakul 19 September 2018

Is it love that I have to-day? Love, that bloom'd early, has it bloom'd late......so touching and impressive. Beautiful poem.

1 0 Reply
Adrian Flett 19 September 2018

The likeness to music in a minor or a major key, is the love that is experienced when it is young and new but not as enduring as the love, more mature of friendship.

1 0 Reply
Bernard F. Asuncion 19 September 2018

Such a great poem by Amy Levy...................................

1 0 Reply
Ruta Mohapatra 19 September 2018

So many beautiful lines, the poem is full of them! Such truths about the heart's own ways that we scarcely understand! A masterpiece!

1 0 Reply
Amy Levy

Amy Levy

London
Close
Error Success