Monday, March 14, 2016

I Am A Talky Comments

Rating: 0.0

(Poem on talkative people.)


I am a talky;
...
Read full text

Shahid Saleem Butt
COMMENTS
Shahid Saleem Butt 16 March 2016

Thanks Mike Smith and anticipating some comments on my other poems.

0 0 Reply
Mike Smith 15 March 2016

So glad to see you edited this Shahid. Now you've made something relatable and worthy of recognition. Thank you

1 0 Reply
Shahid Saleem Butt 16 March 2016

always ready to accept truth. thanks again

0 0
Shahid Saleem Butt 16 March 2016

thanks again. can you give a review of my other poems?

0 0
Mike Smith 14 March 2016

You say the poem is about talkative people, but you reference several times talkative girls and not guys. This makes it come off rather bigoted in my opinion. Incessant talking can get to ones nerves I suppose. Agree there. But this poem implies that only girls talk incessantly, and not only that, but that they do so BECAUSE they are girls and can't help it. It's the epitome stereotyping and it's simply not accurate. My suggestion, either massively edit the piece to leave gender out, or just pull the poem off the site. Hate to be discouraging, but this is not a good poem or a good message to send

2 0 Reply
Shahid Saleem Butt 16 March 2016

i could not reply earlier. thanks for reading and then suggesting the way to set the things right. regards

0 0
Shahid Saleem Butt

Shahid Saleem Butt

Gujranwala
Close
Error Success