Sunday, February 22, 2009

He Said No Comments

Rating: 5.0

i asked him did he love me he said yes,
asked, did he want to have a baby..yes
did he want to call him Jamie and again yes.
...
Read full text

SarahLouise Malone
COMMENTS
Aaron Graham 22 February 2009

wow, awesome economy of words, felt like 90% of the poem was all in my head between the lines, few poems can create that type of interface, bravo. If I may, perhaps to even monoploise further on its economy, some words may not even have to be repeated to retain cogency. i asked did he love me, he said yes, did he want to have a baby..yes did he want to call him Jamie, again yes. (the shift from 3rd to 2nd person in this line threw me a bit but if it was intentional, I would be most interested in your rationale, I almost want to say it does sound better in the 2nd person, but is it to achieve something i'm missing here...also, i think the and before the again breaks flow while just the 'again' still retains meaning) he asked me did i feel it was working, i said yes would i marry him..yes did i want to make it work for the kids again yes. i asked him was she worth ('it' i beleive that wa just an ommision when posting the poem) he said yes did he love(need a T) he kids..yes , , , , , , ......... , , , , , , , , , , , , was he ever coming back? (or to set it apart furher as unique, maybe 'I then asked him' but the 'i asked him' I think downplays the POP you want the line to give) ? ? he casually(maybe 'casually, he said...no' making the reader pause via a, after casually will put so much more power into the incepid connoation this indifference in such an answer represents, i think.) said..no. great stuff, please, i would love to hear what you think about the comments as the simple dialouge will lead to a deeper undrstanding of the poem for myself, not being the author, cheers!

0 0 Reply
SarahLouise Malone

SarahLouise Malone

Hollis Street
Close
Error Success