Tuesday, December 31, 2002

Cleared Comments

Rating: 2.8

Help for a patriot distressed, a spotless spirit hurt,
Help for an honourable clan sore trampled in the dirt!
From Queenstown Bay to Donegal, O listen to my song,
The honourable gentlemen have suffered grievous wrong.
...
Read full text

Rudyard Kipling
COMMENTS
Sylvia Frances Chan 07 September 2024

MY FINAL COMMENT: TOP Marks for this epic poem, The Classic Poem Of The Day, great choice by Poem Hunter and Team

0 0 Reply
Sylvia Frances Chan 07 September 2024

TWO: who were responsible for the deaths of innocent people. It is a reminder of the importance of justice and the dangers of hatred and violence.

0 0 Reply
Sylvia Frances Chan 07 September 2024

ONE: Kipling was outraged by the verdict, and he wrote the poem to express his anger and disgust. The poem is a powerful and moving indictment of the Irish politicians

0 0 Reply
Steven M 06 March 2022

For context, this is about the Parnell Commission, which investigated the Irish statesman Parnell to determine if he'd supported some recent political assassinations. Parnell was 'cleared, ' but Kipling didn't approve of the verdict...

0 0 Reply
M Sagnik Das 24 May 2017

The charge is old'? - As old as Cain - as fresh as yesterday; Old as the Ten Commandments - have ye talked those laws away? If words are words, or death is death, or powder sends the ball, You spoke the words that sped the shot - the curse be on you all. So good

1 0 Reply
M Sagnik Das 24 May 2017

wowowowwowowowowowow

0 0 Reply
John Richter 03 November 2014

This is an absolutely amazing poem. Every line strummed the beat of meter like a song to me, yet the meat of it is so very intense. I would like to know more about this poem. It sounds as though a thug hired men to intimidate an Irish fellow, but the men killed him instead. And the instigator was cleared because his intention was not murder. And if I'm not mistaken he went on to join British Parliament. Shocking story and I wonder if it is true. Kipling is fastly becoming one of my favorite poets.

4 1 Reply
Jack Growden 04 August 2013

Tremendously passionate piece of poetry! ! Please read my collection! ! I am a young, aspiring poet. Feel free to rate and comment on my pieces. Thanks, Jack Growden

1 2 Reply
Hunter Hunters 04 August 2012

Kipling never went to prison for his words all in the name of poetry. Indeed we are not ruled by murderers but only by their friends. We hope for better future in God's Kingdom.

2 2 Reply
Joseph Poewhit 04 August 2010

Kipling is in a real huff about laws and crime, the written word and curruption of system.

2 3 Reply
Ramesh T A 04 August 2010

Only Kipling knows pretty well what he is talking about!

0 2 Reply
Kevin Straw 04 August 2009

Pretty savage whatever the rights and wrongs of the case! Today there would be a libel case. Only a poem could say what Kipling says.

1 1 Reply
Close
Error Success