Monday, March 1, 2004

California Winter Comments

Rating: 2.8

It is winter in California, and outside
Is like the interior of a florist shop:
A chilled and moisture-laden crop
Of pink camellias lines the path; and what
...
Read full text

Karl Shapiro
COMMENTS
Jim Ewing 22 November 2020

Thank you for honoring one of the most skilled and underrated poets of any generation.

1 0 Reply
Erich R. David 21 November 2020

A fair evocation of California. I have two caveats: “ By noon the fog is burnt off by the sun...” This is a summer weather pattern in California. It rarely happens in winter. “Beautiful they are not; they oppress the heart...” Strange take on the California redwoods. I’ve never met anyone who thought these trees were anything other than beautiful.

2 0 Reply
Bill D 21 November 2020

" oldest living things" clearly refers to the Bristlecone pine, Pinus longaeva, which can reach 4800 years. " gigantism" is confusing, as this certainly suggests the far taller redwoods. To me both are magnificently beautiful, in different ways.

0 0
Harriet Fishlow 21 November 2020

The California of my heart’s desire. An ex pat, this how I remember it.

4 0 Reply
Tom Domer 21 November 2020

The subtle unforced rhyming pattern is brilliant the images evocative and spot on

0 0 Reply
Sonja Renda 20 November 2020

The poetry angel is in the details and words of every line of this poetic evocation of CA.

0 0 Reply
Susan Williams 11 January 2016

But this land grows the oldest living things, Trees that were young when Pharoahs ruled the world, ==== ........ There doesn't seem to be much that this author can't handle, does there? Philosophy, grief, joy, beauty, war, despair, hope .

31 0 Reply
Jim Randolph 16 March 2005

my memory of this last line is Flooding the lowland valleys like the nile not daylong does anyone know which is correct?

2 0 Reply
Karen Winchester 20 November 2020

The Central Valley is at least a daylong drive, and has been known to flood from the San Joaquin and Sacramento Rivers in the winter, much like the Nile. So, Shapiro's phrasing is geographically accurate.

0 0
priskill 11 January 2022

It is 'Flooding the daylong valleys like the Nile' -- I believe it is also a biblical allusion but do not quote me.

0 0
Karl Shapiro

Karl Shapiro

Baltimore, Maryland
Close
Error Success