Saturday, October 11, 2014

Bereft Comments

Rating: 3.1

Where had I heard this wind before
Change like this to a deeper roar?
What would it take my standing there for,
Holding open a restive door,
...
Read full text

Robert Frost
COMMENTS
Tom Revitt 06 October 2018

Interesting how God comes in at the end. But it is not the Christian God, the benevolent god, but the pagan god of the universe that does what he will

3 4 Reply
Jonathan 11 June 2019

Where do you get that idea? Was Frost an atheist? It's not at all apparent from the poem.

3 0
Sybarite123 11 February 2021

I strongly disagree. Frost here is indeed referring to the Christian God. Only the Christian God can confort you and be a real friend. A retired Catholic priesr

4 3
Thomas Revitt 19 September 2018

I don't see a problem with the meter; it does slightly shift but that is consistent with the disintegration in mood. Tone theme and effect are heightened, don't you think?

5 0 Reply
stephanie walter 31 August 2018

I love Frost. He was of his time. There are problems w the meter here - but I still come back to this again and again... the encroachment of old age - the loneliness of another season passed. Pure genius

4 1 Reply
Ruta Mohapatra 23 April 2018

A very poignant poem. Frost at his best!

3 0 Reply
Walterrean Salley 24 November 2016

(Bereft by Robert Frost.) The end justifies the means.

2 2 Reply
Susan Williams 22 March 2016

This poem weeps actual tears and it opens the doors of our soul to the gray cold winds of winter and bereavement. Frost knows we live an essentially lonely lives at times like this when we would love a friend's comforting and silent arm around us

26 1 Reply
Brian Jani 26 April 2014

Awesome I like this poem, check mine out

7 8 Reply
Soma Sengupta 14 January 2014

Nothing else to say. Cannot be said better.

10 2 Reply

When you are old and left out cold In some lonely place you call home And few come to call, i am often told Then God moves in and takes you in His fold..... I welcome all reading this to my page too for your valuable comments

27 3 Reply
* Sunprincess * 26 October 2012

Wow! You realize God is all you need.. when God is all you have left..fabulous! .. :)

33 48 Reply
Brian 26 May 2022

I think you missed the meaning. He's been left alone by a cruel God taken his loved ones away, a malevolent nature ready to take him next. Cloud rise, wind picks up, hardly celebratiion.

10 3
Sara S 22 January 2010

Only God...

25 29 Reply
Jane Moon 27 August 2009

This poem conveys a mood of great aloneness: awareness of time moving on ('summer was past and the day was past') , a somber and sinister aloneness. Surely there is a great sense of mourning.

27 11 Reply
Andrew Hoellering 31 May 2009

You guys make it sound as though being alone is an un-American activity! In fact it is a necessary prelude to reflections which in turn has led to some of the greatest poems in the English language - Tennyson's In Memoriam, Wordsworth's Prelude and Matthew Arnold's Dover Beach come to mind. Frost belongs to this elite group who are able to withdraw into themselves and come up with something capable of changing our lives.

31 9 Reply
Robert Quilter 16 December 2008

apparently Frost felt more alone than others...re; 'acquainted with the night'

19 7 Reply
DOT H 07 April 2008

Even those great poets and poems have the same feeling.. Being alone.. alas! ! !

17 10 Reply
Tom Revitt 06 October 2018

Even loneliness is not alone, to exist it must have a context

1 0
Fanny Lei 26 February 2005

The speaker feels lonely, because he has lost someone (from the title bereft) . There' re part indicate the speaker wishes to die. 'Summer was past and day was past' mean the ending of life. Day was past mean it's night, and night mean the end of something.

26 12 Reply
Robert Frost

Robert Frost

San Francisco
Close
Error Success